Top 5 Best Soft Tool Bags

is made possible by its users.
When you buy a product through a link on our site, we may earn a commission. Learn More.

The 5 Best Soft Tool Bags

The best soft tool bags or open-type of toolboxes are a staple of many professions. These types of professions usually need to carry their tools into a job site, office or home environment. As such, they need a tool box or carrier of their tools that can be easily reached and carried with comfort. The soft or cloth tool bag is different than the metal tool boxes or home tool kits that are typically seen in homes or apartments. Check out our soft tool bag reviews and ratings below.

The 5 Top Soft Tool Bags

Presented below are the detailed reviews of the 5 best soft tool bags. As you are looking at the below, note the material the tool bag is made from and the tools that can beheld. Make sure it can and does hold the tools you need. The rankings & reviews below are for the best soft tool bags to use in your business or profession.

Editor’s PicksBrandRating
Best ChoiceStanley STST70574 12-Inch Soft Sided Tool Bag★★★★★
Premium PickDEWALT DG5543 16-Inch Tradesman’s Tool Bag★★★★★
Best ValueWORKPRO 16-inch Wide Mouth Tool Bag with Water-Proof Molded Base★★★★☆
Most DurableCustom Leathercraft 15 Pocket 16 in. Center Tray Tool Bag★★★☆☆
Best Beginner FASTPRO F00651 36-Piece Basic Home Tool Set with 12-inch Tool Bag★★★☆☆

Ratings are determined using our specialized 5-star rating system.

Best Choice: Stanley STST70574 12-Inch Soft Sided Tool Bag

★ Best Choice
Top 5 Best Soft Tool Bags 1Top 5 Best Soft Tool Bags 2

Stanley STST70574 12-Inch Soft Sided Tool Bag

The Stanley STST70574 12-Inch Soft Sided Tool Bag is a basic but very good soft tool bag.

The Stanley STST70574 12-Inch Soft Sided Tool Bag is a basic but very good soft tool bag. What makes us give it our highest ranking of FIVE STARS? Well, out of all we reviewed, its adjustable strap and very comfortable cotton padded handle was by far the best. It also has something most do not, a rubber foam bottom that helps keep the soft tool bag sturdy and protects the contents from falls.

Because of its streamlined design and sturdy construction, we give the Stanley STST70574 12-Inch Soft Sided Tool Bag our highest ranking of FIVE STARS!

Item Key Features:

  • Adjustable strap with cotton-padded handle for comfortable transportation
  • Rubber foam base to reinforce the structure of the bag
  • 12 internal and external pockets for tool storage
  • Durable polyester fabric designed to hold up against heavy use

Premium Pick: DEWALT DG5543 16-Inch Tradesman’s Tool Bag

♛ Premium Pick
Top 5 Best Soft Tool Bags 3Top 5 Best Soft Tool Bags 4

DEWALT DG5543 16-Inch Tradesman’s Tool Bag

Though several other soft-sided tool bags are also great buys, we chose the DEWALT DG5543 16-Inch Tradesman’s Tool Bag as our premium pick for several reasons.

Though several other soft-sided tool bags are also great buys, we chose the DEWALT DG5543 16-Inch Tradesman’s Tool Bag for several reasons. The bag has 14 interior pockets, which also includes a zippered pocket. The canvas tool bag is also highly durable and strong as it is made from heavy duty poly and ballistic poly fabric. One of the best tool bags to be found on the market! PROS of the Dewalt DG5543 Tradesman Tool Bag are that its made with heavy duty construction material, it has 14 interior pockets + zippered pocket, 4 base pads (footers) and a non-slip adjustable padded shoulder strap. The CONS of the Dewalt DG5543 Tradesman Tool Bag are that moderately expensive compared to other brands (though it contains tools already!) and there are a few reports of stitching issues.

Because of its high storage capabilities and heavy-duty construction, we give the Dewalt DG5543 Tradesman Tool Bag our highest rating at FIVE STARS!

Item Key Features:

  • Non-slip adjustable padded shoulder strap for easy transportation
  • 4 base pads to secure the bag while it’s seated
  • 14 interior pockets for tool storage
  • Durable polyester fabric designed to hold up against heavy use

Best Value: WORKPRO 16-inch Wide Mouth Tool Bag with Water-Proof Molded Base

$ Best Value
Top 5 Best Soft Tool Bags 5Top 5 Best Soft Tool Bags 6

WORKPRO 16-inch Wide Mouth Tool Bag with Water-Proof Molded Base

The WORKPRO 16-inch Wide Mouth Tool Bag with Water-Proof Molded Base is a great budget option because it offers more than most soft tool bags of comparable size and price.

The WORKPRO 16-inch Top Wide Mouth Tool Bag has 13 outside pockets and 8 belts. This is a bit more than most soft tool bags of comparable size and price. The pockets on the inside and outside of the polyester bag consist of 8 pockets inside with 3 on each side and two pockets on the two ends. In other words, plenty of pockets and a large inside area as well measuring 16-inch lengthwise by 9-inch wide and 9.5-inch tall.

Because of the amount of storage this tool bag offers at its price point, we give the WORKPRO 16-inch Wide Mouth Tool Bag an excellent rating of FOUR STARS!

Item Key Features:

  • Carrying handle and over-the-shoulder strap for versatile transportation options
  • Waterproof base to protect tools from rust and short-circuiting
  • 8 interior pockets and 13 exterior pockets, as well as 8 belts for versatile storage of tools
  • Durable polyester fabric designed to hold up against heavy use

Most Durable: Custom Leathercraft 15 Pocket 16 in. Center Tray Tool Bag

♥ Top Pick
Top 5 Best Soft Tool Bags 13Top 5 Best Soft Tool Bags 14

Top Pick: Custom Leathercraft 15 Pocket 16 in. Center Tray Tool Bag

The Custom Leathercraft 15 Pocket 16 in. Center Tray Tool Bag is a different sort of soft tool bag.

The Custom Leathercraft 15 Pocket 16 in. Center Tray Tool Bag is a different sort of canvas tool bag. Its different in that it is open on the top. The soft tool box includes a 13-1/2 inch by 9 inch compartment plastic tray that fits within the bag. On the outside of the bag are 8 pockets with another 8 on the inside.

Though durable, because there’s no lid or ability to close the tool bag, we give the Custom Leathercraft 15 Pocket 16 in. Center Tray Tool Bag a good rating of THREE STARS.

Item Key Features:

  • Padded shoulder strap and carry handles for comfortable transportation
  • Rubber foam base to reinforce the structure of the bag
  • 17 pockets and sleeves plus tape measure and electrical tape strap for tool storage
  • Durable leather and polyester fabric designed to hold up against heavy use

Beginner Pick: FASTPRO F00651 36-Piece Basic Home Tool Set with 12-inch Tool Bag

♥ Top Pick
Top 5 Best Soft Tool Bags 15Top 5 Best Soft Tool Bags 16

Top Pick: FASTPRO F00651 36-Piece Basic Home Tool Set with 12-inch Tool Bag

Though several other soft-sided tool bags are also great buys, we chose the FASTPRO F00651 36-Piece Basic Home Tool Set with 12-inch Tool Bag because it serves as a good tool bag and a basic tool kit for beginners.

Though several other soft-sided tool bags are also great buys, we chose the FASTPRO F00651 36-Piece Basic Home Tool Set with 12-inch Tool Bag for several reasons. First, and most important, is that this soft bag already come loaded with tools! It includes slip joint pliers, groove joint pliers, adjustable wrench, long nose pliers, 7-in-1 magnetic screwdriver holder, screwdriver bits, utility knife and a tape measure. It is made from polyester fabric and has a wide opening.

Though the bag itself is simple, this is a great starting kit for a beginner DIYer. Because of the tools that come with it, we give the FASTPRO F00651 36-Piece Basic Home Tool Set with 12-inch Tool Bag a good rating of THREE STARS!

Item Key Features:

  • Cotton-padded carrying handle for comfortable transportation
  • Comes with complete set of basic tools for beginner crafters
  • 12 internal and external pockets for organizing your tools
  • Durable polyester fabric designed to hold up against heavy use

Who Should Buy a Soft Carry Tool Bag?

It’s important for any craftsman to be able to take their tools with them when going out to a job. Tool boxes and tool bags have existed for nearly as long as tools have, and they serve an important role in tool organization and transport. However, you may find yourself trying to decide between a tool box with a drawer liner and a canvas tool bag and wondering which is the best option.

Tool bags have a versatility to them that metal tool boxes, portable rolling tool boxes, and tool belts don’t have, and it’s that versatility that serves as their biggest asset. Tool bags weigh less than tool boxes and tool carts, so for a DIYer on the go, a tool bag may make a big difference in how difficult it is to get tools to the jobsite. Tool bags are also often available at a lower price point for comparable storage capabilities to a tool box.

However, if you are a craftsman who carries extremely heavy tools around on a regular basis, a soft carry tool bag may not be the right choice. Instead, a metal tool box may be a better option, because canvas tool bags may begin to tear at the seams over time when over-encumbered.

Tool bags are additionally less durable than tool boxes, so they offer less protection for tools and will wear out more quickly than a box. So if you work in an environment where your tools may be at risk for damage, or if your tool bag is likely to be knocked around, a tool box may be a safer option to protect your equipment.

However, if you use your tools in a low-risk environment, don’t need to carry around heavy-weight tools, and just need to move your tools from one area to another, a canvas tool bag is a fantastic investment that offers the same value as a tool box at a lower price point that simply can’t be beat. It’s also lighter, which is great for an electrcian tool bag because you have to carry it from site to site. Not sure which tool storage option is right for you? Check out our tool box buyers guide for additional information.

The Advantages of Having a Soft Tool Bag Important Features to Consider

When buying a soft carry tool bag, it’s important to know before buying what features are available and what features will meet your needs as a crafter. Here are a few popular features often found in the best tool bags:

  • Adjustable padded strap and handles available for over-the-shoulder and hand carry depending on your needs
  • Sturdy fabric and stitching that can stand up to heavy use
  • Enough pockets to store all tools and small parts necessary
  • Sturdy zipper to protect tools
  • Reinforced base to protect tools and maintain the shape of the bag
  • Waterproofing or water resistance in the fabric to prevent damage to tools

Not all of these features are necessary in a tool bag, so it’s important to evaluate which features are the most important for your needs. For our favorite canvas tool bag that meets a majority of these specifications, check out the DEWALT DG5543 16-Inch Tradesman’s Tool Bag. This tool bag features 14 interior pockets, as well as an adjustable shoulder strap, non-slip hand-carry handle, sturdy reinforced fabric, and a reinforced base to protect tools.

Conclusion

Remember when reviewing soft tool bags, the most important things are not the price, but the quality of the bag and its capacity to carry the gear you need, even larger tools. Review and compare the construction of the material, the compartments and the handles and straps. All can vary from bag to bag, so make sure you do your research before you make a purchase.