The 5 Best Metal Tool Boxes

The best metal tool box is the classic tool storage option that every craftsman should have. With all the options out there, choosing the top tool box can be difficult. There are different types and brands of tool boxes, and they often look the same until you pick them up and inspect them.

A tool box is such a simple thing, and yet, who would have thought it would be so difficult to choose one? Fortunately, our metal toolbox reviews and buying guide is here to assist and help you. We also have a top tool box buying guide to assist you. Below, you’ll find metal tool box reviews and ratings for our favorite models.

The 5 Top Metal Tool Boxes

Below are our reviews of the 5 best metal tool boxes and tool chest reviews. Note that when reading the reviews, always check the size, the material it is made from, handles, and if it’s a metal tool box with drawers. And always think safety! The below rankings and reviews are for the best metal tool box made from metal.

Editor’s PicksBrandRating *
Best ChoiceStanley STST19501 Auto Slide Drawer Metal Tool Box, 19-Inch♥♥♥♥♥
Premium PickCraftsman 3-Drawer Metal Steel Chest Toolbox♥♥♥♥♥
Best ValueExcel TB140-Black 20-Inch Metal Steel Tool Box♥♥♥♡♡
Most DurableHomak BW00200240 24Inch Industrial Steel Toolbox♥♥♥♥♡
Most LightweightExcel TB137 Red 1-Tray Steel Tool Box♥♥♥♡♡

*Ratings are determined using our specialized rating system.

Best Choice: Stanley STST19501 Auto Slide Drawer Metal Tool Box, 19-Inch

★ Best Choice
The Top 5 Best Metal Tool Boxes 1The Top 5 Best Metal Tool Boxes 2

Stanley STST19501 Auto Slide Drawer Metal Tool Box, 19-Inch

The Stanley STST19501 Auto Slide Drawer Metal Tool Box is unique among our best metal tool box picks. It features a unique storage system and is designed to handle heavier loads than your average metal tool box.

The Stanley STST19501 Auto Slide Drawer Metal Tool Box stands out because of its unique storage system among comparable metal tool boxes. The top drawer is the main draw of this tool box. It slides towards the back in order to get into the lower storage compartment. The drawer also moves on ball bearing slides, as opposed to a simple metal-on-metal slider.

When you’re on the go, this top tool box has an automatic locking mechanism that keeps the drawer closed when the toolbox is being picked up and moved. The handle on top is somewhat larger than most, as the manufacturer states it is easier to balance a heavier toolbox with a wider and longer handle. This product is designed from the ground up to ensure smooth and easy transportation, no matter how heavy your tools are.

Because of the ball-bearing drawer, the unique construction, and the slightly larger size of the toolbox, we give the Stanley STST19501 Auto Slide Drawer Metal Tool Box, 19-Inch toolbox our highest five star rating.

Item Key Features:

  • Long handle for weight distribution and balance for heavy tools
  • Ball-bearing drawer sliders
  • Large drawers for efficient tool storage
  • Backwards-opening top drawer

Premium Pick: Craftsman 3-Drawer Metal Steel Chest Toolbox

♛ Premium Pick
The Top 5 Best Metal Tool Boxes 3The Top 5 Best Metal Tool Boxes 4

Craftsman 3-Drawer Metal Steel Chest Toolbox

With a rugged design and heavy weight construction, this Red Craftsman Tool Box will be handed down from generation to generation. For its size and durability, this toolbox has won our “Premium Pick” placement as an excellent choice in the best metal toolboxes.

Compared to other toolboxes, the Craftsman 3-Drawer Metal Steel Chest Toolbox is a step above the rest, in that it is an advanced toolbox that can meet anyone’s storage and durability needs. This Craftsman tool box has three drawers, whereas many of its competitors either have fewer or no drawers at all. When you’re on the go, your tools will remain safe: the drawers will not open unless the lid is already open, which is a very handy safety measure.

The pros of the Craftsman 3-Drawer Metal Toolbox include its heavy-gauge construction, a latching lid, three drawers, and larger size. The cons of the Craftsman 3 Drawer Toolbox are that it is moderately expensive, and has smaller drawer sizes. Ultimately, we think this is the best tool box for home, because with its size and weight, it may be more difficult to transport than another top tool box. We give the Craftsman 3-Drawer Metal Toolbox our highest ranking of Five Stars.

Item Key Features:

  • Thick metal frame for durability
  • Three-drawer storage system
  • Latching lid for secure transportation
  • Larger size compared to other tool boxes

Best Value: Excel TB140-Black 20-Inch Metal Steel Tool Box

$ Best Value
The Top 5 Best Metal Tool Boxes 5The Top 5 Best Metal Tool Boxes 6

Best Value: Excel TB140-Black 20-Inch Metal Steel Tool Box

The Excel TB140 20-Inch Black Metal Steel Tool Box is a classic and straightforward tool box for the crafty toolsmith who doesn’t need all the bells and whistles in their metal tool box. With its simple design and lower price point, this toolbox has won our “Best Value” pick for the best metal tool boxes.

An all-around good tool box, the Excel TB140 20 Inch Black Metal Steel Tool Box is a classic and durable product when you don’t need specialized equipment for the job. This tool box features a full length piano hinge that holds the main metal box for increased durability over other tool boxes that traditionally have two or three individual hinges.

The steel tool box is painted black using an industrial power coat method. It has one removable metal tray with a carry handle attached. This is a good all-around toolbox, though because it doesn’t have drawers or many extras, and the metal walls are somewhat thin, we give the Excel TB140 20 Inch Black Metal Steel toolbox our three star rating.

Item Key Features:

  • Piano hinge for increased durability
  • Industrial powder coat to protect from scratches and dents
  • Lightweight frame for ease of transport
  • Classic design for everyday use

Most Durable: Homak BW00200240 24Inch Industrial Steel Toolbox

♥ Top Pick
The Top 5 Best Metal Tool Boxes 13The Top 5 Best Metal Tool Boxes 14

Top Pick: Homak BW00200240 24Inch Industrial Steel Toolbox

This tool box is perfect for the crafter who works hard with their tools. Durability and size is the name of the game with this one. This tool box is made of thicker metal and has a larger size compared to many of the other best metal tool boxes without sacrificing affordability.

The Homak 24 Inch Industrial Steel Tool Box is one of the sturdiest choices for someone who does heavy-duty work with their tools. The tool box has three front latches, with one having a hole to secure a padlock. Though most other toolboxes only have one or two, this ensure that this top tool box is much more durable than its competitors. And with metal walls that measure in a 0.8mm thickness, it’s also thicker and sturdier than the other options on this page. For a handyman who knows their toolbox will need to withstand a beating, the Homak 24 Inch Industrial Steel Tool Box is one of the sturdiest tool boxes for its price.

Instead of a power-type glossy and shiny paint covering, it is covered with a brown wrinkle powder paint covering. Included in the tool box is a removable tray that measures 31 1/2″ long by 4 3/4″ deep by 1 1/2″ deep and is divided into two equal sections. The tray can be slid backwards, forwards, or be removed altogether. Because of the thicker steel construction and the removable tray, we give the Homak 24 Inch Industrial Steel Tool Box our four star rating.

Item Key Features:

  • Triple latch for increased support security
  • Thicker metal walls for durability
  • Removable inside tray for on-the-go work
  • Large size compared to other options

Lightweight Pick: Excel TB137 Red 1-Tray Steel Tool Box Review

♥ Top Pick
The Top 5 Best Metal Tool Boxes 15The Top 5 Best Metal Tool Boxes 16

Top Pick: Excel TB137 Red 1-Tray Steel Tool Box Review

The Excel TB137-Red Steel Tray Tool Box is the perfect tool box for a hobbyist. Smaller and lighter than many of the other options, this tool box works best for someone who doesn’t yet have a wide array of tools or need something more durable.

The Excel TB137-Red Steel Tray Tool Box has one metal tray and is painted red with an industrial powder coat paint finish. The overall dimensions are 16.9 inches long, with a 7-inch depth. It is 7.2 inches high.

The piano lid hinge spans the entire lid length. There is only one metal latch to lock the lid onto the toolbox. The tray has no unique features, but it is removable to add more versatility to the box. This is a great light-use tool box for a hobbyist. Because of the somewhat thinner construction metal and the lack of a larger hole to place a lock in the latch, we give the Excel TB137-Red 1-Tray Steel toolbox a three star rating.

Item Key Features:

  • Piano hinge for increased durability
  • Industrial powder coat to help protect from scratches
  • Lightweight frame for ease of transport
  • Classic design for everyday use

Who Should Buy a Metal Tool Box?

The best metal tool box can be a significant investment, so it’s important to evaluate if a metal tool box is the right choice for you and your storage needs. Metal tool boxes are extremely durable and can last a lifetime (or several), but they’re heavy and can be unwieldy for anyone who has to carry their tool box everywhere.

Do you do a lot of heavy-duty work with tools? If your tool box is going to see long-term use or be battered and banged around, a metal tool box will provide a greater value to you than less durable tool boxes that might wear out quickly. However, if you’re gentle with your tool boxes, a plastic tool box or a soft tool bag may be a better investment.

Another important factor is how often you travel with your tool box. Metal tool boxes are notorious for being heavy and difficult to haul around, especially if there are a lot of tools inside of them. A metal tool box may make travel difficult and be a poor choice for anyone who has to spend a lot of time walking around carrying their tools. However, if your tools don’t need to be moved often, a metal tool box is better investment than a plastic tool box for its durability.

Important Features to Consider

When buying a metal tool box, it’s important to know before buying what features are available and what features will meet your needs as a crafter. Here are a few popular features often found in metal tool boxes:

  • a blue metal tool box Removable interior tray for quick access to tools
  • Drawers to provide internal organization for the tool box
  • Subdivided trays for organization of small parts like nails, screwdriver heads, and drill bits
  • Latch hole to enable locking of tool box with a padlock when the tools are not in use
  • Heavy-duty or light frames to ensure extra durability or to offset the weight of the metal container
  • Powder coating to protect the metal against rust and scratches
  • Ball bearing drawer slides to allow drawers to move in and out more smoothly

Not all of these features are necessary in even the best metal tool box, so it’s important to evaluate which features are the most important for your needs. For our favorite tool box that meets a majority of these specifications, check out the Stanley STST19501 Auto Slide Drawer Metal Tool Box, 19 Inch. This tool box features a ball-bearing supported drawer, heavy-duty metal frame, locking hole for a padlock, a protective powder coat, and an extended bar handle to support the weight of the tool box.

Conclusion

Though there are many other top metal toolboxes on the market, the five toolbox choices above include light use and heavy use and win our praise as the best metal tool boxes around. Some are cheaper than others, and some have more features than others. When choosing a metal toolbox, know if you will be using it inside or outside and if you will need a heavy-duty toolbox or a light-weight one. If a metal toolbox doesn’t fit your needs, then try a good tool belt that you put around your waist.

Choose the best metal tool box for yourself today so you can rest easy knowing your tools are safe in a durable tool box sure to last for years.