Menu

The Top 5 Best Steel Toe Boots for Your Safety

is made possible by its users.
When you buy a product through a link on our site, we may earn a commission. Learn More.

The 5 Best Steel Toe Boots

The best steel toe boots can protect you from injuries and keep you comfortable on your feet through each and every workday. If that sounds too good to be true, then you might benefit from upgrading your professional footwear.

Ready to get started? Jump into this guide to read our steel toe boot reviews and ratings – and how to choose the right ones for you.

The 5 Top Steel Toe Boots

To protect your feet from injury and permanent damage, it’s important to find the best steel toe shoes for your needs. Here are the top steel toed boots on the market today to start your search off right.

Editor’s PicksBrandRating *
Best ChoiceCaterpillar Men’s Salvo 8″ Waterproof Steel Toe Boot♥♥♥♥♥
Premium PickThorogood Men’s American Heritage 8″ Moc Toe, MAXWear 90 Safety Toe Boot♥♥♥♥♥
Best ValueCONDOR Dakota Men’s 8″ Steel Toe Work Boot♥♥♥♥♡
Best WesternDurango Men’s 11 Inch Pull-On Steel Toe DB4343 Western Boot♥♥♥♥♡
Best AthleticReebok Work Men’s Athletic Oxford Industrial & Construction Shoe♥♥♥♡♡
is made possible by its users.
When you buy a product through a link on our site, we may earn a commission. Learn More.

* Ratings are determined using our specialized rating system.

Best Choice: Caterpillar Men’s Salvo 8″ Waterproof Steel Toe Boot

★ Best Choice
The Top 5 Best Steel Toe Boots for Your Safety 1The Top 5 Best Steel Toe Boots for Your Safety 2

Caterpillar Men’s Salvo 8″ Waterproof Steel Toe Boot

Like most in their line, the American Heritage 8″ Moc Toe, MAXWear 90 Safety Toe Boot only uses high-quality full-grain leather and a comfortable synthetic slip-resistant sole.

As the leader in the heavy-equipment industry, Caterpillar is definitely a name you can trust, and their Caterpillar Men’s Salvo 8″ Waterproof Steel Toe Boots live up to the hype. With 100 percent leather uppers and rubber sole, these boots perform exceptionally well in all weather conditions and across all types of surfaces. Even oil-slicked areas are no challenge with the slip-resistant outsole guarding your every step.

Their ASTM-certified steel toe caps provide the protection you seek while Goodyear Welt Construction ensures these boots flex in all the right places — and allow you to replace the soles in the future. Caterpillar went one step further in ensuring these boots protect from injuries by using a PVC midsole to help absorb electric shocks.

These comfortable steel toe boots go beyond safety to improve your comfort as well. Caterpillar went all out with the molded footbed insole that provides extra cushion with every step you take. As an added benefit, their waterproof construction and moisture-wicking materials promise to keep your feet dry all day long. With their patented insultation throughout, these boots can also help you stay warm in the winter and cool in the summer.

With their rugged construction and leather materials, these boots not only perform well, but look the part as well. Consider a pair if you want a heavy-duty work boot with the protective elements you need to stay safe on the job.

Pros:

  • Waterproof leather upper
  • Oil, slip, and shock resistant
  • Optimal flexibility

Cons:

  • Laces may break fast
  • Stitching wears out quickly
  • Leather scuffs easily without proper care

Premium Pick: Thorogood Men’s American Heritage 8″ Moc Toe, MAXWear 90 Safety Toe Boot

♛ Premium Pick
The Top 5 Best Steel Toe Boots for Your Safety 3The Top 5 Best Steel Toe Boots for Your Safety 4

Thorogood Men’s American Heritage 8″ Moc Toe, MAXWear 90 Safety Toe Boot

With their futuristic design, the CONDOR Dakota 8″ Steel Toe Work Boot invokes a love it or leave it feel. In my eyes, these boots are fit for everything from moon landings to construction work.

Thorogood makes it their mission to use the finest materials and proven techniques to construct their steel toe work boots. Like most in their line, the American Heritage 8″ Moc Toe, MAXWear 90 Safety Toe Boot only uses high-quality full-grain leather and a comfortable synthetic slip-resistant sole.

Available in two beautiful natural leather shades, these classic work boots look as stunning as they feel. In fact, they promise to feel broke in and ready to go from day one. Ensuring your comfort are cushioned insoles and footbeds designed for the ultimate in shock absorption. Although they are not waterproof, they can remain water-resistant with regular maintenance and oiling.

While you remain comfortable in these boots, the safety toe always remains ready to protect against impacts and compressive forces. Their non-slip synthetic sole helps prevent slip and fall injuries and provides electric shock resistance up to 18,000 volts. Although the original sole does wear out quickly, the Goodyear welt construction ensures you can replace it when need be. If all that is not enough, you can feel great about your purchase as well, since these boots are made in the USA by union-represented individuals.

Pros:

  • Attractive appearance
  • Durable construction
  • Allows for sole replacement

Cons:

  • Premium price
  • Limited widths
  • Minimal upper padding

Best Value: CONDOR Dakota Men’s 8″ Steel Toe Work Boot

$ Best Value
The Top 5 Best Steel Toe Boots for Your Safety 5The Top 5 Best Steel Toe Boots for Your Safety 6

CONDOR Dakota Men’s 8″ Steel Toe Work Boot

For the look of a classic cowboy boot and the protection of steel toe footwear, take a peek at the Durango 11″ Pull-On Steel Toe Western Boot.

With their futuristic design, the CONDOR Dakota 8″ Steel Toe Work Boot invokes a love it or leave it feel. In my eyes, these boots are fit for everything from moon landings to construction work. Their unique look begins with the AM-TECH Direct Soling Technology, which creates direct-injected outsoles that easily bind to the upper section. Their 100 percent genuine nubuck leather comes in tan and dark brown tones that look great and resist scuffing.

Their unique manufacturing process produces a boot that is extremely lightweight but does not stand up well to the test of time. The foam-like sole material quickly wears down, though is highly comfortable in the meantime. Unfortunately, these boots do not have Goodyear welt construction, so when the sole wears out, you must replace them altogether.

While they last, these boots can help keep you comfortable while standing on your feet all day. If you buy a size up, you can fit a cushion insole over the existing one to boost your comfort even more.

Pros:

  • Lightweight
  • Comfortable
  • Excellent toe protection

Cons:

  • Runs very small
  • Poor durability
  • No electric shock resistance

Best Western: Durango Men’s 11 Inch Pull-On Steel Toe DB4343 Western Boot

♥ Top Pick
The Top 5 Best Steel Toe Boots for Your Safety 13The Top 5 Best Steel Toe Boots for Your Safety 14

Durango Men’s 11 Inch Pull-On Steel Toe DB4343 Western Boot

For the look of a classic cowboy boot and the protection of steel toe footwear, take a peek at the Durango 11″ Pull-On Steel Toe Western Boot.

For the look of a classic cowboy boot and the protection of steel toe footwear, take a peek at the Durango 11″ Pull-On Steel Toe Western Boot. Made from 100 percent leather materials, these boots can stand up to the toughest of jobs and look amazing every step of the way. The full-grain leather has a distressed finish for an old-fashioned look, which is further elevated by the iconic square toe.

The sturdy tabs at the top allow you to pull on this boot with ease. Without any laces to tie, or replace, this work boot offers a truly fuss-free experience. Upon slipping your feet inside, you will notice that their contoured insole provides immense cushion. If you do not find that insole desirable, you can easily remove and replace it with your preferred option.

At the exterior, you are treated to a slip and oil-resistant outsole that is built to resist abrasions. This boot takes a beating as a result. With their steel toe caps, these boots provide exceptional protection against impacts and other forces encountered in your workplace.

Pros:

  • Generous toe box
  • Robust construction
  • High-quality materials

Cons:

  • Heavy
  • Requires thick boot socks
  • Lack of electric shock protection

Best Athletic: Reebok Work Men’s Athletic Oxford Industrial & Construction Shoe

♥ Top Pick
The Top 5 Best Steel Toe Boots for Your Safety 15The Top 5 Best Steel Toe Boots for Your Safety 16

Reebok Work Men’s Athletic Oxford Industrial & Construction Shoe

With the Reebok Work Men’s Athletic Oxford Industrial & Construction Shoe, a little flexibility goes a long way — though the steel toe ensures you do not have to compromise on safety.

With the Reebok Work Men’s Athletic Oxford Industrial & Construction Shoe, a little flexibility goes a long way — though the steel toe ensures you do not have to compromise on safety. These iconic work shoes look like regular sneakers, but perform like a tough work boot. Unlike the leather options, they are made from 100 percent mesh materials that maximize breathability and comfort. This material choice keeps these shoes lightweight despite having heavy-duty alloy toe caps.

Since they have a low-top sneaker design, these comfortable steel toe boots do not provide any protection to your ankles and calves. They also do not have an oil or slip-resistant sole to help protect against slip and fall injuries. These work shoes are comfortable, however, as they have flex grooves and soft insoles to support and cushion your feet as you work.

These shoes are best worn with thick socks, as the thin ones will wear through rubbing on the steel toe box. The narrow toe box does not work for everyone either, but they do offer these comfortable steel toe boots in wide sizes.

Pros:

  • Unique design
  • True breathability
  • Lightweight construction

Cons:

  • Not oil, slip or shock resistant
  • Tight toe box
  • Poor durability

Who Should Buy Steel Toe Boots?

As there are many different types of work boots, the main advantage of wearing the steel toe variety is injury protection. With their reinforced steel toe caps, these boots can protect your feet from injuries caused by impacts and compressive forces. As long as they have oil and slip resistant properties, they can protect from slip and fall injuries as well.

If you work anywhere with heavy equipment, steel toe boots are essential for your safety. At any point, if there’s something that can fall or roll onto your feet, it’s best to be safe and invest in the protective shoes. This doesn’t just mean working with heavy materials. A hammer or other hand tool made of metal could still break toes if it were to fall on your feet, and so almost everyone who works in a workshop should invest in comfortable steel toe boots for their own protection.

With comfortable steel toe boots looking out for your safety, you can remain focused on the job at hand and productive at all times. You can head into your tasks with confidence that your boots will keep you steady on your feet and moving forward with your workday. In this way, your boots even have the potential to help you land that raise or promotion with ease.

With their cushioned insoles and midsoles, quality steel toe boots keep your feet as comfortable as they are protected. You can end the long workday without experiencing serious soreness in your feet after switching to high-quality steel toe boots. You just have to know which pair will best meet your needs and the demands of the job.

Important Features to Consider

There are a number of features to consider when buying steel-toe boots, including size, material, shape, and more. Here are a few qualities your boots should have to ensure your comfort and safety.

Characteristics of High-Quality Steel Toe Boots

Not all steel toe boots are made the same, but it can be difficult to know just what to look for in quality professional footwear. To help you tell the difference between the options, here are a few of the key characteristics of high-quality steel toe boots.

a pair of steel toe boots that have been posed to show them off Real Leather Materials

Any steel toe boot worth its salt is made from real leather materials through and through. The leather materials bend and flex with your movement, remaining durable, yet becoming more comfortable with each wear. The only exception are boots that come in sneaker form with mesh throughout for exceptional breathability and comfort.

ASTM-Certified Steel Toe

High-quality boots should meet the American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM) standard F2413-11. To meet this standard, the boots must prove they can protect against high compressive loads and impacts from heavy falling objects. Steel toe boots that do not meet this standard could fail under heavy loads, causing injury to your feet.

Insole and Midsole Cushion

When you remain on your feet all day, nothing should stand in the way of your comfort. With high-quality steel toe boots, you can still keep your eye on safety while enjoying truly comfortable footwear. The quality boots have extra cushion and reinforcement at the insole and midsole that reduce fatigue and sore feet.  

Oil and Slip Resistance

Beyond protecting your toes, quality steel toe boots also need to prevent injuries from falls with oil and slip resistant properties. Whether made from rubber or synthetic materials, the outsole should have a non-slip surface that keeps you sure on your feet across all surfaces.

By looking for these characteristics during your search, you can narrow down your options and find your perfect work boots.

Top Accessories for Steel Toe Boot Wearers

If you want to make the most out of every wear, you have the right type of socks on hand through each season. Pick up a collection of thick and thin boot socks that wick away moisture and keep your feet dry. The socks should add a little extra cushion to your boots to protect the tops and sides of your feet from chafing.

In addition to good socks, you should also have:

  • Insoles
  • Shoelaces
  • Leather cleaner and conditioner
  • Boot brush
  • Drying stand

With these accessories, you can use your steel toe boots to the fullest extent and keep them in great shape as well.

How to Choose the Best Steel Toe Boots

With your eye on several high-quality boot options, it is important to know how to choose the best steel toe work boots for your needs. Before you can turn your attention to comfort, you must confirm that all your options meet your workplace requirements in full.

After that, you can start digging through the options with a fit check. While trying on each option, check for:

  • Proper Length: With the boots fully-laced, slide your toes all the way forward, bend your knee, and slide one finger down your heel. You should have just enough room for your finger in a well-fitting pair of steel toe boots.
  • Adequate Width: The sides of the boot should feel snug on your feet, not at all tight. You should have room under the steel toe cap to wiggle your toes freely, but not enough to shift your entire foot side to side with the boots laced.
  • Flex at the Sole: After checking length and width, check flex to ensure proper fitment with the flex test. A well-fitting boot will flex precisely at the ball of your foot, which will help prevent rubbing and irritation with movement.

As you try on the options, don’t be shy. Walk around the store wearing each pair of boots to really gauge their comfort and fit. Compare the fit of each boot to the next to determine which ones feel the best on your feet.

You cannot go wrong with the boots that have all the right characteristics and the fit to match. So, if you find ones that fit well, you are well on your way to enjoying the perfect mix of comfort and safety.

Conclusion

a pair of muddy steel toe boots When it comes to great steel toe boots, you just cannot compromise on safety and comfort — and the Thorogood American Heritage 8” Moc Toe, MAXWear 90 Safety Toe Boot doesn’t even try.

Instead, Thorogood infuses these boots with all the characteristics that makes them the best option on the market today. Their attractive appearance, rugged construction and protective features all go a long way in making them the top steel toe boots.

At the most expensive, they are a true investment in your comfort, safety, and career. Thankfully, with their Goodyear welt construction, you can replace the sole and get your money’s worth from every pair.